Talk:Gallery Tagging

To Be Added

Content/fetishes

slave

Real porn fetishes

tattoo?
twin tails

To Be Edited

Know The Difference - bondage vs. bdsm vs. torture

All costume / clothing fetishes:

• May only be tagged for females unless yaoi / genderbending takes place.
• May only be tagged if they are still at least partially worn during sexual activities. If they are removed completely beforehand the tag is not valid.

Questions

Acceptable tags?

all the way through

blood

muscle growth

snuff

vampire

vore - counts as weight gain or inflation?

Expunging Tags

already uploaded

A gallery of the same or superior quality was already posted.

compilation

A combination of works that are supposed to be posted separately (multiple volumes, different translations, completely different comics, etc.)

excessive minor updates

A gallery that has been updated more than twice per sliding month (except for "as published", such as for ongoing translations).

prohibited content

Anything on the Do-Not-Post list. Any amateur / non-verifiable real porn. Any 3d lolicon / shotacon.

realporn

Any real pornography that does not belong to either Cosplay or Asian Porn categories. Any non-nude asian porn galleries.

replaced

A gallery of superior quality has been posted.

How To Determine If A Tag Is Good

See how well it passes the following 4 questions:

1. Do people search with this tag?

2. Is this tag clearly defined?

3. Is this tag NOT better substituted with another?

4. Do people vote on this tag accurately and frequently?

Split content into more than one page

I suggest that the content currently on this page be split. The first half or so (from the beginning through the Bad Tags section) is mostly a guide. The latter half (from What are Slave Tags? through Known Issues) is more of a FAQ.

Having both of those parts in the same page makes it quite long, but on top of that, it lacks focus. The first half of this page tells a user how to tag; that's all that needs to be on such a page. If a user wants to know about mod power or tag colors or something, then 1) they're likely to read a page called a "FAQ" or similar, 2) it would help them to actually separate out the FAQ topics from the guide topics.

If you split the page, all you have to do is include a link to the new FAQ page in the lead section (and probably See Also) to ensure that people won't miss it.

Eh, not sure what to call the new page, "FAQ" seems sorta okay but I'm open to suggestions. - Maximum Joe (talk) 14:43, 17 February 2013 (UTC)

The best alternatives I can offer right now are something like "About Gallery Tagging" or "Gallery Tagging Mechanics". PeopleDon'tDanceNoMore (talk) 17:27, 17 February 2013 (UTC)