Talk:Gallery Tagging: Difference between revisions

From EHWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Maximum Joe (talk | contribs)
Maximum Joe (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
== To Be Added ==
==Notes==
=== Content/fetishes ===
*[[furry]] and [[alien]] are not mutually exclusive.
slave
*Creatures from [[pokemon]] are judged between animal, [[monster]], and [[furry]] based on their level of anthropomorphization and animal attributes.
<br>
**Very animalistic ones like [[ponyta]] and [[rapidash]] are generally animals (e.g. [[horse]]s).
**Humanoid-animals like [[pikachu]] and [[mewtwo]] are essentially always [[furry]].
**Very humanoid ones like [[gardevoir]] can be either [[monster]] or [[furry]] depending on how much they resemble a non-human creature.


=== Real porn fetishes ===
==Presence Notes==
tattoo?
*The general 25% rule is a baseline used for the most common gallery (a ~20 page [[doujinshi]]). It does not scale up past that point nor is it ironclad. The general idea is that something tagged is easily found within the gallery and is of a satisfactory amount. Sequential images generally lower the burden to meet minimum presence.
<br>twin tails
**The more fragmented non-sequential images are the less they count.
<br>
*Colophons without illustrations, blank pages, and credits do not count as part of a gallery's image count for presence purposes.
 
*A 4-or-less image gallery can have anything within it be tagged (although this is ill advised for [Ongoing] galleries since the tags may suddenly be disqualified upon more images being added).
=== Gallery descriptors ===
*For [[anthologies]] 4+ sequential images suffices for credited artists.
 
*For all but one of the Change tags only images involving the change itself are counted. For [[gender bender]] the duration of the individual being a different gender also qualifies (assuming sexual activity or non-h presence).
=== Variables ===
*1 image is enough to nullify gallery-wide tags like [[girls only]] / [[guys only]].
 
**Omake/covers/credits/colophons can be ignored for technical tags like [[full color]].
== To Be Edited ==
*Whilst the [[incest]] tag is 1-image only the accompanying family tags (e.g. [[mother]]) are '''not''' and thus do not necessarily qualify if the actual activities involving them is too low in presence.
'''Know The Difference''' - bondage vs. bdsm vs. torture
 
All costume / clothing fetishes:
*May only be tagged for females unless yaoi / genderbending takes place.
*May only be tagged if they are still at least partially worn during sexual activities. If they are removed completely beforehand the tag is not valid.
 
== Questions ==
Acceptable tags?
:'''all the way through'''
:'''blood'''
:'''muscle growth'''
:'''snuff'''
:'''vampire'''
 
'''vore''' - counts as ''weight gain'' or ''inflation''?
 
== Expunging Tags ==
;already uploaded
:A gallery of the same or superior quality was already posted.
;compilation
:A combination of works that are supposed to be posted separately (multiple volumes, different translations, completely different comics, etc.)
;excessive minor updates
:A gallery that has been updated more than twice per sliding month (except for "as published", such as for ongoing translations).
;prohibited content
:Anything on the Do-Not-Post list. Any amateur / non-verifiable real porn. Any 3d lolicon / shotacon.
;realporn
:Any real pornography that does not belong to either Cosplay or Asian Porn categories. Any non-nude asian porn galleries.
;replaced
:A gallery of superior quality has been posted.
 
== How To Determine If A Tag Is Good ==
See how well it passes the following 4 questions:
:'''1'''. Do people search with this tag?
:'''2'''. Is this tag clearly defined?
:'''3'''. Is this tag NOT better substituted with another?
:'''4'''. Do people vote on this tag accurately and frequently?
 
== Split content into more than one page ==
 
I suggest that the content currently on this page be split.  The first half or so (from the beginning through the Bad Tags section) is mostly a guide.  The latter half (from What are Slave Tags? through Known Issues) is more of a FAQ.
 
Having both of those parts in the same page makes it quite long, but on top of that, it ''lacks focus''.  The first half of this page tells a user how to tag; that's ''all'' that needs to be on such a page.  If a user wants to know about mod power or tag colors or something, then 1) they're likely to read a page called a "FAQ" or similar, 2) it would ''help'' them to actually separate out the FAQ topics from the guide topics.
 
If you split the page, all you have to do is include a link to the new FAQ page in the lead section (and probably See Also) to ensure that people won't miss it.
:Eh, not sure what to call the new page, "FAQ" seems sorta okay but I'm open to suggestions. - [[User:Maximum Joe|Maximum Joe]] ([[User talk:Maximum Joe|talk]]) 14:43, 17 February 2013 (UTC)
:: The best alternatives I can offer right now are something like "About Gallery Tagging" or "Gallery Tagging Mechanics". [[User:PeopleDon&#39;tDanceNoMore|PeopleDon&#39;tDanceNoMore]] ([[User talk:PeopleDon&#39;tDanceNoMore|talk]]) 17:27, 17 February 2013 (UTC)
:::Done. Looks very brisk now, should be easier for newbies to chew on. Thanks for the idea! - [[User:Maximum Joe|Maximum Joe]] ([[User talk:Maximum Joe|talk]]) 17:59, 17 February 2013 (UTC)

Revision as of 16:28, 27 March 2015

Notes

  • furry and alien are not mutually exclusive.
  • Creatures from pokemon are judged between animal, monster, and furry based on their level of anthropomorphization and animal attributes.

Presence Notes

  • The general 25% rule is a baseline used for the most common gallery (a ~20 page doujinshi). It does not scale up past that point nor is it ironclad. The general idea is that something tagged is easily found within the gallery and is of a satisfactory amount. Sequential images generally lower the burden to meet minimum presence.
    • The more fragmented non-sequential images are the less they count.
  • Colophons without illustrations, blank pages, and credits do not count as part of a gallery's image count for presence purposes.
  • A 4-or-less image gallery can have anything within it be tagged (although this is ill advised for [Ongoing] galleries since the tags may suddenly be disqualified upon more images being added).
  • For anthologies 4+ sequential images suffices for credited artists.
  • For all but one of the Change tags only images involving the change itself are counted. For gender bender the duration of the individual being a different gender also qualifies (assuming sexual activity or non-h presence).
  • 1 image is enough to nullify gallery-wide tags like girls only / guys only.
    • Omake/covers/credits/colophons can be ignored for technical tags like full color.
  • Whilst the incest tag is 1-image only the accompanying family tags (e.g. mother) are not and thus do not necessarily qualify if the actual activities involving them is too low in presence.