User:Maximum Joe: Difference between revisions

From EHWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Maximum Joe (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Maximum Joe (talk | contribs)
Line 68: Line 68:
*Mixed content
*Mixed content
*Anything with repeats
*Anything with repeats
*Screenshots


====http://static.ehgt.org/images/review/quality-2.gif Get B& Tier====
====http://static.ehgt.org/images/review/quality-2.gif Get B& Tier====

Revision as of 19:00, 16 April 2012

Help out with tagging decisions here. Thanks!

To Do List

  • Fix remaining non-wikitables
  • Add article on Gallery "Modes"
  • Add note about Pony Mode
  • Fix second-person language (i.e. "you" -> "players")
  • Add article on Gallery Descriptions
  • Add note about tagging abuse and bans
  • Find a way to word-wrap preformatted text (the ones with spaces or <pre> before them)

Tagging To-Do List

  • Add artist names to magazines (COMIC Megastore, etc.) as well as indexing them in the comments
  • Add missing fjording tags to older galleries
  • Add character names to Non-H galleries
  • Add "translated" to older translated galleries
  • Clear "asian", magazine names over 2 characters, convention names
  • Fix miscategorizations
  • Fix "etcycle" & "clesta" tags
  • Fix "tattoo" taggings to fit with the current definition
  • Replace "dragon quest", "final fantasy", "gundam", etc. with appropriate subseries name (where applicable)
  • Replace "meganekko" with "glasses"
  • Remove "mother" when there is no "incest"
  • Remove "full color" from CG / 3D galleries
  • Remove "uncensored" from galleries whose content was never expected to be censored
  • Remove "misc" tags on older western galleries
  • Remove redundant category tags under 100 mod power
  • Remove "translated" from non-translated or rewrite galleries
  • Remove "yuri" and "yaoi" from Non-H

Gallery Tier List

The following is how I view content or actions for the galleries. My ratings on galleries tend to reflect this.

quality-10.gif God Tier

  • Buying, scanning, or translating pro bono

quality-10.gif Top Tier

  • Buying, scanning, or translating in exchange for bounties or commissions

quality-8.gif High Tier

  • Rare stuff (old, never available outside of Japan, not found in most stores, etc.)
  • Commissioning for translations
  • Game CG rips
  • Decensoring

quality-6.gif Mid Tier

  • Regular doujin/manga/CG/cosplay/western content
  • Re-uploads of superior quality, including high-res (therefore replacing)
  • Easy to find free porn comics / imagesets
  • Themed galleries of good size and overall quality
  • Coloring
  • Incompletes that are updated within the update limits

quality-4.gif Low Tier

  • Re-uploads of the inferior quality but more content
  • Easy to find free non-porn webcomics / imagesets
  • Galleries with dupes or vague themes
  • Alternative scans
  • Rewrites
  • Out of order
  • Low image count with a reason
  • Incompletes that are never updated or updated too frequently

quality-2.gif Shit Tier

  • "My favorites" / random / no theme at all
  • Low image count when not necessary
  • The same shit we've seen a million times
  • Mixed content
  • Anything with repeats
  • Screenshots

quality-2.gif Get B& Tier

  • Pretty much anything that gets expunged (except being replaced)

expunged.png Call The Fucking Police Tier

  • CP